Retirement plans generally fall into two broad categories: defined contribution plans and defined benefit plans. Most private sector workers today participate in defined contribution plans such as 401(k)s, while many public employees and some private sector workers are covered by defined benefit pensions. Business owners may choose either type, or both, for themselves and their employees. Understanding how each works helps employees plan for retirement and helps owners decide which design fits their goals. If you want help evaluating your retirement plan options, a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review can help.
This guide explains how each type of plan works, who bears the investment risk, how benefits are paid, and how business owners commonly use each type.
How Defined Contribution Plans Work
In a defined contribution plan, the contributions are defined, but the eventual benefit is not. Employees, employers, or both contribute to individual accounts. The account balance at retirement depends on how much was contributed and how the investments performed. Common examples include 401(k), 403(b), 457(b), profit sharing, SEP IRA, and SIMPLE IRA plans.
Key features of defined contribution plans include:
Individual accounts that employees can see and track
Investment choices often made by the employee from a menu of options
Investment risk borne by the employee
Portability, since balances can often be rolled over when changing jobs
Annual contribution limits that apply to employees and employers
Our article on what a 401k is covers the most common defined contribution plan in more detail.
How Defined Benefit Plans Work
In a defined benefit plan, the benefit is defined, usually by a formula based on salary and years of service, and the employer is responsible for funding it. The employer invests plan assets and bears the investment risk. If investments underperform, the employer generally must contribute more to meet the promised benefits. Traditional pensions are the classic example.
Benefits are typically paid as a lifetime annuity, though some plans offer a lump sum option. Our article on pension lump sum vs annuity discusses that choice.
Cash balance plans are a hybrid type of defined benefit plan. Each participant has a hypothetical account that grows with pay credits and interest credits, but the employer still bears the investment risk and the plan is subject to defined benefit funding rules.
Key Differences at a Glance
Who bears investment risk. Employees in defined contribution plans; employers in defined benefit plans.
What is promised. Contributions in defined contribution plans; a benefit formula in defined benefit plans.
How benefits are paid. Account balances in defined contribution plans; usually lifetime income in defined benefit plans.
Portability. Defined contribution balances are generally more portable.
Administrative complexity. Defined benefit plans generally require actuarial work and more complex administration.
What Employees Should Consider
Employees with a defined contribution plan carry the responsibility of saving enough and investing appropriately. Employees with a pension have more predictable retirement income but may have less flexibility, and the value of the benefit often depends on staying with the employer long enough to earn it. Many people have both over a career. Coordinating a pension with personal savings, Social Security, and withdrawal strategy is a central part of retirement income planning.
Public employees in Wisconsin often participate in a state retirement system that combines features of both approaches. Understanding how that benefit fits with other savings is an important part of planning.
Why Business Owners Consider Defined Benefit Plans
For business owners with high and stable income, defined benefit or cash balance plans can allow much larger tax-deductible contributions than defined contribution plans alone, particularly for older owners. These plans are often paired with a 401(k) and profit sharing plan. The tradeoffs include required annual contributions, actuarial and administrative costs, and the obligation to fund benefits for eligible employees. Our article on cash balance plans for business owners explains how these plans commonly work.
Choosing a Plan Design as an Owner
Owners evaluating plan designs commonly consider:
How much they want to save for themselves each year
How stable business cash flow is, since some plans require annual funding
The ages and pay of employees, which affect costs and testing
Administrative costs and the time required to manage the plan
How long they expect to keep the plan in place
Because plan design affects taxes, employee benefits, and long-term savings, it is often reviewed with a third-party administrator, an actuary for defined benefit plans, and a tax professional.
Tax Considerations
Contributions to both types of plans are generally tax-deductible for the employer, and pre-tax employee contributions to defined contribution plans reduce current taxable income. Distributions in retirement are generally taxable as ordinary income, except for qualified Roth amounts. Wisconsin generally follows federal treatment, with certain subtractions for retirement income that may apply to some retirees. Coordinated tax planning and preparation helps owners see how plan contributions interact with other parts of their return.
Combining Both Types in a Household Plan
Many households end up with both kinds of plans. One spouse may have a pension from a school district or government employer while the other saves in a 401(k). A business owner may have a cash balance plan alongside a 401(k) and profit sharing plan. Planning around both involves deciding how much lifetime income the pension provides, how much the defined contribution savings need to supplement it, and how to invest the defined contribution accounts given that steady pension base. A household with substantial pension income may be able to take a different approach with its other savings than one that relies entirely on personal accounts. Coordinating survivor options on the pension with beneficiary designations on retirement accounts also helps protect a surviving spouse.
Next Steps
Whether you are an employee in Madison weighing a pension and a 403(b), or a business owner in Waunakee considering a cash balance plan, understanding the differences between plan types can help you make more informed decisions.
To review your retirement plan options, request a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between defined contribution and defined benefit plans?
Defined contribution plans define contributions to individual accounts. Defined benefit plans define the retirement benefit, usually by formula, with the employer bearing investment risk.
Is a 401(k) a defined contribution plan?
Yes. A 401(k) is a common type of defined contribution plan.
Is a pension a defined benefit plan?
Traditional pensions are defined benefit plans. Cash balance plans are a hybrid form of defined benefit plan.
Why would a business owner choose a defined benefit plan?
Owners with high, stable income may use defined benefit or cash balance plans to make larger deductible contributions, subject to funding requirements and costs.
Who bears investment risk in each plan type?
Employees generally bear investment risk in defined contribution plans, while employers bear it in defined benefit plans.
Compound is a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. Strategies discussed may not be suitable for everyone, and there is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives or reduce taxes. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Please consult your tax, legal, and financial professionals before acting on any information in this article. For more information, see Compound's Form ADV, available at adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Information may be generalized or subject to change. Please contact our team for the most current and accurate information.
About Compound Wealth
Long-term financial planning often involves balancing tax considerations, investment decisions, business interests, and personal financial goals. Compound Wealth provides an integrated planning approach that brings these disciplines together to provide a coordinated framework for evaluating financial decisions as financial circumstances evolve over time.