Most married couples file a joint tax return, and for many that is the simplest and most favorable choice. But married filing separately exists for a reason, and in certain situations it can make sense. The decision involves taxes, credits, student loans, liability, and in Wisconsin, the state's marital property rules. Because the right answer can change from year to year, it is worth understanding the tradeoffs rather than defaulting to one option. If you would like help comparing filing statuses, a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review is a good starting point.
This guide explains how each status generally works, situations where filing separately may be considered, the drawbacks of filing separately, and Wisconsin-specific considerations.
How Each Filing Status Works
When married couples file jointly, they combine income, deductions, and credits on one return, and both spouses are generally responsible for the full tax owed. When they file separately, each spouse reports their own income and deductions on a separate return.
The tax brackets for married filing separately are generally narrower than the joint brackets, so for many couples the combined tax on two separate returns is the same or higher than on one joint return. That is why joint filing is the most common choice.
Situations Where Filing Separately May Be Considered
Income-driven student loan repayment. Some repayment plans base payments on income reported on the tax return. Filing separately may lower the payment for the spouse with the loans, though the tax cost and plan rules need to be compared.
Liability concerns. A spouse who is uncomfortable with the accuracy of the other spouse's income reporting, or who is separated, may prefer to be responsible only for their own return.
Large medical expenses. Medical expenses are deductible only above a percentage of adjusted gross income. If one spouse has large medical costs and lower income, filing separately may make more of those costs deductible in some cases.
Separation or pending divorce. Couples who are living apart and keeping finances separate may choose to file separately.
Each of these situations still requires running the numbers, because the benefits may be offset by the drawbacks below.
Drawbacks of Filing Separately
Filing separately can limit or eliminate several tax benefits. Depending on current law, these may include education credits, the earned income credit, certain child and dependent care benefits, the ability to deduct student loan interest, and contributions to a Roth IRA, which can be sharply limited for married people filing separately who lived together during the year. If one spouse itemizes deductions, the other generally must itemize as well. Social Security benefits may be more likely to be taxable for married filing separately. These rules change, so confirm them each year.
Wisconsin and Marital Property
Wisconsin is a marital property state, which is similar to community property rules in other states. In general, income earned during marriage is considered owned equally by both spouses. That affects how income is reported when spouses file separately. Federal and Wisconsin rules include provisions for how marital property income is allocated, and there are exceptions and elections that can apply in some situations.
Wisconsin also offers a married couple credit for two-earner couples who file jointly, which is not available to those filing separately. Our article on estate tax planning in Wisconsin discusses marital property in the estate context.
Innocent Spouse Relief and Joint Liability
Because joint filers are generally each responsible for the full tax, a spouse may become liable for errors or omissions on the other spouse's income. Federal law offers relief provisions, sometimes called innocent spouse relief, in certain circumstances. These are fact-specific and can be difficult to obtain. A spouse with concerns about the other's reporting may want to discuss options with a tax professional before signing a joint return.
Running the Comparison
The most reliable way to choose is to prepare the return both ways and compare the results, including federal and Wisconsin taxes, effects on credits, and any non-tax considerations such as student loan payments. Many tax professionals run this comparison when a couple's situation suggests filing separately might help. Our tax planning and preparation team can model both options.
Changing Your Mind After Filing
In general, couples who filed separately may be able to amend to file jointly within the time allowed for amended returns. Changing from a joint return to separate returns after the filing deadline is generally more limited. This asymmetry is another reason to think carefully before filing.
Filing Status After Major Life Changes
Filing status is generally determined by marital status on the last day of the year, which means life changes late in the year can affect the entire year's return. Couples who marry in December can generally file jointly for that year. Couples who divorce before year end generally cannot. A spouse who dies during the year can generally still be included on a joint return for that year, and a surviving spouse with a dependent child may qualify for a special filing status for a limited period afterward.
These transitions often bring other financial decisions, such as retitling accounts, updating beneficiaries, and adjusting withholding. Our articles on divorce financial planning and financial planning for widows address those situations in more depth.
Next Steps
For most married couples in Madison, Waunakee, and across Wisconsin, filing jointly will be the simpler and more favorable option. For some, especially those with student loans, liability concerns, or major medical expenses, a comparison is worth the effort.
To compare filing statuses and see how your return fits your broader plan, request a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to file jointly or separately?
Most couples pay less filing jointly, but separate filing can make sense in certain situations such as income-driven student loan repayment or liability concerns.
Does Wisconsin's marital property law affect separate returns?
Yes. Wisconsin's marital property rules affect how income is allocated between spouses who file separately, with certain exceptions.
Can I contribute to a Roth IRA if we file separately?
Roth IRA contributions are sharply limited for married people filing separately who lived together during the year. Check current rules.
Can we switch from separate to joint after filing?
Generally, couples can amend to file jointly within the time allowed. Switching from joint to separate after the deadline is more limited.
Who is responsible for taxes on a joint return?
Both spouses are generally responsible for the full tax on a joint return. Relief provisions exist but are fact-specific.
Compound is a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. Strategies discussed may not be suitable for everyone, and there is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives or reduce taxes. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Please consult your tax, legal, and financial professionals before acting on any information in this article. For more information, see Compound's Form ADV, available at adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Information may be generalized or subject to change. Please contact our team for the most current and accurate information.
About Compound Wealth
Long-term financial planning often involves balancing tax considerations, investment decisions, business interests, and personal financial goals. Compound Wealth provides an integrated planning approach that brings these disciplines together to provide a coordinated framework for evaluating financial decisions as financial circumstances evolve over time.