Hiring the first employee is a milestone for any small business. It also brings a new set of tax responsibilities. Payroll taxes involve withholding from employee wages, paying employer taxes, making deposits on schedule, and filing returns throughout the year. Mistakes in this area can become expensive quickly, and some payroll tax obligations can even become the personal responsibility of owners. If you want help making sure payroll fits cleanly into your accounting and tax processes, a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review is a good place to start.
This guide explains, in general terms, the main types of payroll taxes, how deposits and filings work, Wisconsin considerations, and common mistakes to avoid.
The Main Types of Payroll Taxes
Payroll taxes generally fall into two groups: amounts withheld from employees and amounts paid by the employer.
Withheld from employees:
Federal income tax, based on the employee's Form W-4
Wisconsin income tax, based on the employee's state withholding form
The employee share of Social Security and Medicare taxes
Paid by the employer:
The employer share of Social Security and Medicare taxes
Federal unemployment tax
Wisconsin unemployment insurance tax
Rates, wage bases, and thresholds for each are set by law and adjusted periodically, so check current figures when setting up or reviewing payroll.
Deposits and Filing Schedules
Employers generally must deposit withheld and employer payroll taxes on a schedule determined by the size of their tax liability, often monthly or semiweekly. Deposits are typically made electronically. Employers also file quarterly federal payroll returns, annual unemployment returns, and annual wage statements such as W-2s for employees. Wisconsin has its own withholding deposit and reporting requirements, along with quarterly unemployment insurance reporting.
Missing a deposit or filing deadline can lead to penalties, even if the tax is eventually paid. A calendar of all payroll deadlines, federal and state, is one of the simplest tools an employer can keep.
Employees vs Independent Contractors
Whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor affects payroll tax obligations. Employers generally withhold and pay payroll taxes for employees, but not for independent contractors, who receive Form 1099-NEC instead. The classification depends on the actual working relationship, including how much control the business has over how and when work is done. Misclassifying employees as contractors can lead to back taxes, penalties, and interest. Wisconsin applies its own tests for unemployment insurance and other purposes.
Owner Compensation and Payroll
How owners are paid depends on the business structure. Sole proprietors and partners generally do not receive W-2 wages from their own business and instead pay self-employment tax. S corporation owners who work in the business generally must receive a reasonable salary through payroll, with taxes withheld and paid like any other employee. Our guide on how to pay yourself as a business owner covers those decisions, and our article on SEP IRA vs Solo 401k explains related retirement plan considerations.
Benefits and Payroll
Many benefits run through payroll, including retirement plan deferrals, health insurance premiums, and health savings account contributions. Some are pre-tax for income tax purposes, some for payroll tax purposes, and some for both. Setting these up correctly in the payroll system matters, since errors can affect employee W-2s and employer filings. Fringe benefits, such as personal use of a company vehicle, may also need to be included in wages.
Common Payroll Tax Mistakes
Missing deposit deadlines or depositing the wrong amount
Misclassifying employees as independent contractors
Failing to set up Wisconsin withholding and unemployment accounts
Using outdated withholding forms or not collecting them at hire
Forgetting to include taxable fringe benefits in wages
Not reconciling payroll reports with the general ledger
Using payroll tax funds to cover other business expenses during a cash crunch
The last item deserves emphasis. Taxes withheld from employees are held in trust for the government. If they are not paid, certain responsible individuals, including owners, may be held personally liable through the trust fund recovery penalty.
Payroll Services and Recordkeeping
Many small businesses use a payroll service to calculate withholding, make deposits, and file returns. Even with a service, the employer remains responsible for accuracy and timeliness. Reviewing payroll reports each period, reconciling them to the books, and keeping records of filings and payments helps catch problems early. Ongoing client accounting services can help keep payroll, bookkeeping, and tax planning aligned.
Hiring Your First Employee in Wisconsin
For a business hiring its first employee, a short setup checklist can help. Steps commonly include obtaining a federal employer identification number if the business does not have one, registering with the Wisconsin Department of Revenue for withholding, registering with the Department of Workforce Development for unemployment insurance, reporting new hires as required, and collecting Forms W-4, Wisconsin withholding forms, and employment eligibility verification at hire. Many businesses also need workers compensation coverage, which is handled through insurance rather than payroll taxes.
Once payroll is running, a monthly reconciliation between payroll reports and the general ledger, and a quarterly review of filings, can catch errors early. Setting up the payroll system correctly at the start is usually easier than correcting it later, especially for benefits and fringe items. Owners who expect to grow may also want to consider how retirement plans and other benefits will be offered as the team expands.
Next Steps
Whether you are hiring your first employee in Waunakee or managing a growing team in Madison, payroll taxes are a core part of running a business in Wisconsin. A clear process for withholding, deposits, and filings helps reduce risk and keeps your focus on growing the business.
To review how payroll fits with your accounting and tax planning, request a complimentary, no-obligation wealth and tax review. Our tax planning and preparation team works with small business owners across Wisconsin.
Frequently Asked Questions
What payroll taxes do small businesses pay?
Employers generally withhold income tax and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare, and pay the employer share plus federal and state unemployment taxes.
How often do I deposit payroll taxes?
Deposit schedules are generally based on the size of your tax liability, often monthly or semiweekly.
Do I withhold taxes for independent contractors?
Generally no. Independent contractors receive Form 1099-NEC and handle their own taxes, but classification depends on the working relationship.
Can owners be personally liable for payroll taxes?
Yes. Responsible individuals may be held personally liable for unpaid withheld taxes through the trust fund recovery penalty.
Do S corporation owners need to run payroll?
S corporation owners who work in the business generally must receive a reasonable salary through payroll.
Compound is a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. Strategies discussed may not be suitable for everyone, and there is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives or reduce taxes. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Please consult your tax, legal, and financial professionals before acting on any information in this article. For more information, see Compound's Form ADV, available at adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Information may be generalized or subject to change. Please contact our team for the most current and accurate information.
About Compound Wealth
Compound Wealth works with business owners, entrepreneurs, professionals, and families with increasingly complex financial lives. The firm brings together tax planning, wealth management, client accounting services, and business transition advisory to provide a coordinated planning experience. By evaluating multiple aspects of a client's financial picture together, planning discussions may become more structured and aligned with long-term goals.